MLS in Data: Most Successful Clubs in MLS Cup Playoffs

By: AT

Image Credit: Sports Events 365

The 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs are here, and they officially begin on November 19! This year, the nine highest-ranked clubs from each conference qualify for the postseason.

Since 2023, in each conference, the eighth-place club hosts the ninth-place club in a one-match preliminary round, with the winner advancing to the conference quarterfinals and facing the highest-ranked club of the conference (one of those two clubs is the reigning MLS Supporters’ Shield winner). This year’s matches are: Orlando City SC (8th) versus FC Cincinnati (9th) in the Eastern Conference and Seattle Sounders (8th) versus Real Salt Lake (9th) in the Western Conference. The Orlando—Cincinnati winner will play against Nashville SC, which won the 2026 MLS Supporters’ Shield title and achieved the record for most points in an MLS regular season (77). The Seattle—Salt Lake winner will play against Vancouver Whitecaps.

The conference quarterfinal matches, which take place from November 22 to December 2, adopt a format similar to those in Major League Baseball, National Basketball Association and National Hockey League playoffs. In this round, the 16 remaining MLS clubs will compete in a best-of-three series, with the higher-ranked club hosting matches one and three (if necessary). The conference semifinals, conference finals and MLS Cup Final are one-match knockout rounds. The match dates for those rounds are the following:

  • Conference semifinals (eight participants): December 5–6

  • Conference finals (four participants): December 11–12

  • MLS Cup Final (two participants/conference winners): December 18

In this 10th piece of our MLS in Data collection, we evaluate the overall MLS Cup Playoffs performances of all 30 active clubs and of the three former MLS clubs’* based on the following categories:

  • MLS Cup Playoffs qualifications;

  • MLS Cup titles and MLS Cup Final appearances; and

  • MLS Cup Playoffs match victories.

Number of MLS Cups Playoffs Qualifications

From the MLS’s inaugural season in 1996 to 2026, all 30 active MLS clubs have qualified for the MLS Cup Playoffs at least once (See Figure 1). New York Red Bulls (NYRB) lead all active clubs in playoff qualifications, with 25. LA Galaxy and FC Dallas rank second and third in this category, with 22 and 21 qualifications, respectively.

MLS Cup Playoffs Qualifications by Club (1996–2026)

MLS Cup Playoffs Qualifications by Club (1996–2026)

New York Red Bulls 25; FC Dallas 22; LA Galaxy 21; Columbus Crew 20; Sporting KC 20; New England Revolution 18.

Italics indicate that the club is inactive. Tampa Bay competed in MLS from 1996 to 2001; Miami from 1998 to 2001; and Chivas USA from 2005 to 2014.

FC Dallas competed as Dallas Burn from 1996 to 2004; Sporting KC competed as Kansas City Wiz in 1996 and as Kansas City Wizards from 1997 to 2010; New York Red Bulls competed as MetroStars from 1996 to 2005; and San Jose Earthquakes competed as San Jose Clash from 1996 to 1999.

San Jose Earthquakes relocated to Houston and became "Houston Dynamo" in 2005. In 2008, San Jose regained a team, naming themselves "San Jose Earthquakes" and retaining all rights to the former "San Jose Earthquakes" club, including matches played, match victories and all titles.

Sources: Major League Soccer and Squawka

Among the inactive MLS clubs, Miami Fusion and Tampa Bay Mutiny — both of which folded after the 2001 season — qualified for the MLS Cup Playoffs on three and four occasions, respectively. Chivas USA, a former satellite club of Liga MX’s CD Guadalajara, qualified for the playoffs four times.

Number of MLS Cups and MLS Cup Final Appearances

According to our data, since D.C. won the inaugural MLS Cup, 14 other clubs have won the elusive piece of silverware (see figure 2). After 1996, D.C. added three more titles (1997, 1999 and 2004). However, LA Galaxy (LAG) — another founding club — now hold the record for most MLS Cup titles (2002, 2005, 2011, 2012, 2014 and 2024).

MLS Cup Titles and MLS Cup Final Appearances

MLS Cup Titles and MLS Cup Final Appearances

Winners Finalists (Runners-up)
LA Galaxy 6 wins, 4 runner-up; D.C. United 4 and 1; Columbus Crew 3 and 1; New England Revolution 0 and 5.

FC Dallas competed as Dallas Burn from 1996 to 2004; Sporting KC competed as Kansas City Wiz in 1996 and as Kansas City Wizards from 1997 to 2010; New York Red Bulls competed as MetroStars from 1996 to 2005; and San Jose Earthquakes competed as San Jose Clash from 1996 to 1999.

San Jose Earthquakes relocated to Houston and became "Houston Dynamo" in 2005. In 2008, San Jose regained a team, naming themselves "San Jose Earthquakes" and retaining all rights to the former "San Jose Earthquakes" club, including matches played, match victories and all titles.

Source: Major League Soccer

Other notable MLS Cup achievements include:

  • Houston Dynamo, the only other club to have won back-to-back MLS Cup titles, in 2006 and 2007;

  • Toronto FC, the first — and still only — Canadian club to win the MLS Cup, in 2017; and

  • Atlanta United, which hoisted the MLS Cup in 2018, the club’s second season in MLS.

Moreover, MLS supporters have enjoyed their fair share of iconic MLS Cup Finals. For example, there have been two six-goal matches at this stage: a 4-2 San Jose Earthquakes victory against Chicago Fire in 2001 and a Los Angeles FC (LAFC) victory on penalties after drawing Philadelphia Union 3-3 after extra-time. That latter match marked the final club appearance of then-LAFC forward Gareth Bale, who retired after representing Wales at the 2022 FIFA World Cup in Qatar.

Another iconic story includes the inter-conference rivalry between Toronto and Seattle Sounders, which duelled in three MLS Cup Finals in only four years: 2016, 2017 and 2019. While Toronto memorably won the 2017 edition (2-0 at home), Seattle hoisted the cup in 2016 and 2019. The 2016 edition ended on penalties after a scoreless contest after extra-time, while the 2019 edition ended in a dominant 3-1 home victory for Seattle. Notably, Seattle’s 2016 triumph was the first and only time that a club won the MLS Cup Final without recording a single shot on goal.

Inter Miami enter 2026 as the defending MLS Cup champions, having won the 2025 MLS Cup after defeating Vancouver 2-1 at home. Both clubs made their MLS Cup Final debuts.

Winning the MLS Supporters’ Shield: A Curse?

Normally, the MLS Supporters’ Shield winners are favourites to hoist the MLS Cup. Historically, however, winning the MLS Supporters’ Shield and MLS Cup in the same season has been achieved only eight times, and by six clubs. D.C. United were the first to do so in 1997 and 1999, which was followed by Sporting KC (then Kansas City Wizards) in 2000.

LA Galaxy and D.C. United are the sole clubs to have won both MLS Supporters’ Shield and MLS Cup in the same season on multiple occasions, with the Galaxy achieving that feat in 2002 and 2011.

Columbus Crew completed the domestic double in 2008. Nine years later, Toronto FC became the first — and only — Canadian club to win both trophies. They also added the 2017 Canadian Championship title to their trophy cabinet.

Los Angeles FC are the most recent club to achieve this milestone, having done so in 2022.

Number of MLS Cup Playoffs Match Victories

Based on our match data collected from MLS Cup Playoffs editions over the 1996 to 2025 period, LA Galaxy have the highest number of MLS Cup Playoffs match victories among all active and former MLS clubs, with 48 (see Figure 3). Columbus rank a distant second, with 28 victories. Rounding out the top five clubs in this category are Seattle, D.C. and NYRB. They boast 26, 23 and 22 playoff match victories, respectively.

With respect to win percentage, LA Galaxy also rank first, at 62.3%. Local rivals LAFC and San Diego FC rank second and third in this category, at 61.9% and 60.0%, respectively. Rounding out the top five are Toronto FC (58.8%) and Inter Miami (54.5%)

MLS Cup Playoffs Victories and Win Percentage by Club (1996–2025)

MLS Cup Playoffs Victories and Win Percentage by Club (1996–2025)

LA Galaxy 48 victories (62.3%); Columbus Crew 28 (43.1%); Seattle Sounders 26 (49.1%); D.C. United 23 (47.9%); New York Red Bulls 22 (33.3%).
Number of Victories Win Percentage

Italics indicate inactive club. Tampa Bay competed in MLS from 1996 to 2001; Miami from 1998 to 2001; and Chivas USA from 2005 to 2014.

Victories include matches won in regulation- or extra-time, including via sudden-death extra-time.

FC Dallas competed as Dallas Burn from 1996 to 2004; Sporting KC competed as Kansas City Wiz in 1996 and as Kansas City Wizards from 1997 to 2010; New York Red Bulls competed as MetroStars from 1996 to 2005; and San Jose Earthquakes competed as San Jose Clash from 1996 to 1999.

San Jose Earthquakes relocated to Houston and became "Houston Dynamo" in 2005. In 2008, San Jose regained a team, naming themselves "San Jose Earthquakes" and retaining all rights to the former "San Jose Earthquakes" club, including matches played, match victories and all titles.

Source: Major League Soccer


*The three inactive Major League Soccer (MLS) clubs are Miami Fusion, Tampa Bay Mutiny and Chivas USA. Tampa Bay competed in MLS from 1996 to 2001; Miami from 1998 to 2001; and Chivas USA from 2005 to 2014.

Next
Next

MLS in Data: Most Successful Cascadian Major League Soccer Club